top of page

Fabric or Steel? What to Weigh Before Adding Overflow Grain Storage

10 minutes ago
7 min read

Editor's Note: Grain Guy Fifty would like to thank Braden Chupp and Covermore Buildings for contributing this article. Braden’s experience with fabric building applications as grain storage provides a practical insight for facility managers, maintenance personnel, and grain operations considering short term, temporary, or emergency storage alternatives.


A big crop, a slow basis or a late elevator line can leave a farm with more grain than bin space. When that happens, the choice is usually made in a hurry: pile it, rent space, or put up a building. Each option can work. The ones that go wrong are usually the ones chosen without thinking through the ground, the air and the years the structure will need to serve.


Tension fabric buildings have become a common answer for overflow and contingency storage, and steel buildings remain the long-standing default. Neither is right for every farm. This article walks through the questions that actually separate them, so the decision fits the grain and the operation instead of the calendar.


Start with how long the grain will sit

The first question is not fabric or steel. It is how long the grain needs to be held and how often the space will be needed.


A one-time emergency, a few months between harvest and a spring delivery, is a different problem from a recurring shortfall every fall. A structure that will be filled and emptied every year needs to stand up to loaders, augers and weather for a long time. A short-term need may be better served by a covered pile or commercial space, and it is worth pricing those honestly before building anything.


Sara Bauder, an extension agronomy field specialist with South Dakota State University, put the priority plainly: the main thing is a facility that is safe, keeps grain dry, and has aeration for temperature control. Any building that cannot do those three things is not grain storage, no matter what it costs.


Grain pushes on walls

This is the point most often missed. Grain does not just sit on the floor. A pile leaning against a wall pushes outward on it, and the force grows with the depth of the grain.


A fabric membrane is not designed to hold back grain. Neither is the sheeting on a typical steel machine shed. In either building, if grain will be piled against the sides, the walls that touch the grain need to be engineered for that load. In practice that usually means a concrete push wall, precast concrete blocks, or a steel bin-style retaining wall around the inside, with the building's frame carrying only the roof and the weather.


The common wall setups are:

• Precast interlocking concrete blocks or poured concrete push walls along the sides, with the building set on top of them or just inside them. This is the most common choice for grain and feed ingredients, because the concrete takes the outward push and the building only has to cover it.

• Shipping containers as the wall line. Some fabric buildings are mounted on rows of containers, which gives a solid, heavy wall on each side and some covered, lockable storage inside the containers themselves. The containers still need to be treated as a wall: grain piled against them should stay within what that setup is rated for.


Fertilizer needs extra care. It is hard on steel, so keep the product off the frame entirely. Concrete walls, a good floor and a dry frame matter more there than with grain.


However the walls are built, how high the pile can go should be set by the wall's own engineering, not by the building. Before buying any building for grain, ask the supplier one direct question: is this structure rated for grain against the walls, and to what depth? If the answer is vague, plan on free-standing walls inside it, or keep the pile peaked in the center with clearance to the sides. A wall failure loses the grain, the building and possibly the person standing next to it.


Site prep matters more than the building

Most of the grain lost in overflow storage is lost from the bottom, not the top. Moisture wicks up from wet ground and runs in from the edges.


A good site has:

• High, well-drained ground. Water should run away from the building on every side, with no low corner where runoff collects.

• A firm base. Concrete is best for a building that will see repeated use and loader traffic. A compacted gravel pad with a moisture barrier can serve a lighter or shorter-term use, but it is harder to clean out completely.

• Room for equipment. Trucks, a loader and an auger or conveyor need space to turn and dump without hitting the structure. Door width and side clearance should be sized for the biggest machine that will go in.

• Distance from overhead lines. Augers and dump bodies reach high. Site the building where raising equipment never brings it near a power line.


The cost of rain getting in is easy to underestimate. Ken Hellevang, a grain storage specialist with North Dakota State University Extension, has noted that a 1-inch rain can raise the moisture of a 1-foot layer of corn by 9 percentage points. A leak at the base or a puddle at the door can spoil far more grain than its size suggests.


Air: aeration and ventilation are two different jobs

Two kinds of air movement matter in an overflow building, and they are easy to confuse.


Aeration pushes air through the grain to keep it cool and even in temperature. Without it, warm spots develop, moisture migrates, and insects and mold follow. A flat-storage building needs aeration ducts on or in the floor, sized for the volume of grain, and fans to drive them. This is the same principle as a bin, just laid out flat. The grain also needs to go in dry and cool; aeration maintains good grain, it does not fix wet grain.


Ventilation moves air through the space above the grain. When aeration fans push warm, moist air out of the pile, that air has to leave the building. If it cannot, it condenses on the underside of the roof and drips back onto the grain.


Fabric and steel handle this differently:

• Steel roofs heat and cool quickly and are prone to condensation on the underside unless they are insulated or vented. Ridge vents and eave openings help.

• Fabric roofs breathe somewhat differently, and many fabric buildings are open-ended or have large end-wall openings, which helps air escape. Fabric still needs planned venting, usually at the peak and the end walls, sized for the fans that will run.

Either way, plan the exhaust when you plan the fans. A building with aeration and no way for air to leave is a condensation machine.


Light and temperature

Many tension fabric buildings use a white or translucent cover that lets daylight through. That is helpful for working inside without lights, and it reduces the dark, damp corners that make clean-out unpleasant. It also means the top of the pile can see some warming from the sun, so temperature cables or regular probing of the top layer are worth the effort.



Steel buildings are dark inside unless skylight panels are added, and the roof can get hot in summer. Neither is a reason to choose one over the other; both are reasons to monitor grain temperature at the surface, not just the core.


Lifespan and upkeep

Steel framing and steel sheeting last for decades with reasonable care. The weak points are usually rust at the base, fasteners working loose and roof leaks around penetrations.


A fabric building has two parts with different lives. The frame, typically galvanized steel, lasts like any other steel structure. The fabric cover is the wear item. Its life depends on the material, its UV protection and the climate, and manufacturers state it in their warranties. Read that warranty closely, ask what a replacement cover involves, and budget for it the same way you would budget for a roof.


Snow and wind are the other half of lifespan. Any building, fabric or steel, should be engineered for the snow and wind loads where it will stand, and that rating should be in writing. Tension fabric sheds snow well because of the curved roof, but it still has to be tensioned correctly and checked after storms.


Flexibility after the grain is gone

One real difference between the two is what happens in the off-season. A fabric building with clear-span framing and wide end openings can switch easily to machinery, hay or bulk materials. Some can be taken down and moved, which matters for rented ground or a site that may change. A steel building is more permanent, which is a benefit if the location is settled and a drawback if it is not.


Think about the second and third use of the building before you buy it. Storage that earns its keep twelve months a year is easier to justify than storage that sits empty nine of them.


A short checklist before you commit

1. How many bushels, for how long, and how often will the space be needed?

2. Is the structure rated for grain against the walls, and to what depth? If not, which self-supporting walls go inside: concrete block, poured push walls or containers?

3. Is the site high, drained and firm, with room for trucks and a loader?

4. Is aeration sized for the volume, and is there a planned exit for the air?

5. What are the snow and wind ratings, in writing?

6. What is the expected life of each part, and what does upkeep cost over that life?

7. What else will the building be used for?


A farm that can answer all seven has done the real work. After that, fabric versus steel becomes a matter of budget, site and preference, and either can store grain well when it is built for it.


Sources

• Farm Progress, "Options for grain storage" (Oct. 10, 2018), quoting Ken Hellevang, NDSU Extension, and Sara Bauder, SDSU Extension: https://www.farmprogress.com/crops/options-for-grain-storage

• Purdue University, Post Harvest Grain Quality and Stored Product Protection Program, Temporary Grain Storage Considerations: https://extension.entm.purdue.edu/grainlab/


About the author

Braden Chupp is a consultant with Chupp Industrial in Chouteau, Oklahoma, which supplies tension fabric buildings. He keeps a plain-language guide to what fabric buildings cost and why for anyone pricing one.


Hope you found this  post informative.  If you have had any experiences with fabric buildings for grain storage would love to hear your story. Thank you for reading.


Regards,

Grain Guy Fifty

Comments


12 Blakeridge Place, Mt. Zion, IL 62549

© 2035 by Grain Guy 50. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page